Wednesday, April 18, 2007

LS 500 The Notion of Category...

Barite, M. (2000). The Notion of "Category:" Its Implications in Subject Analysis and in the Construction and Evaluation of Indexing Languages. Knowledge Organization 27:4-10.

Introduction

There is not very much written on the topic of categories. This may be as the author suggests due to the fact that categories matter only to classificationists. Barite poses the following question:

What do we designate when we make reference to categories?

Ranganathan brought the concept from Philosophy to the Classification of Knowledge – he constructed a system of classification called the Colon Classification based on his theoretical ideas.

The author does mention that the comprehension of the concept if neither simple nor easily accessible.

Definitions

  • It is not possible to characterize categories in the Theory of Classification.
  • Categories are generally abstract expressions, so they can be perceived in any entity, element or object.
  • Categories simplified as abstractions with the strength of intellectual instruments are used by classificationists to investigate regularities of objects of the physical and ideal world and for representing notions.

Usefulness

  1. Design, planning and structuring of indexing languages or systems of knowledge.
  2. Modification or specification of classification tables.
  3. The evaluation and analysis of indexing languages and systems of concepts through a set of parameters capable of establishing the grade of reciprocal tension among related concepts and their relevance and validity.

Category, Object and Analyst

It is not possible to isolate the notion of category from those of object and analyst. The complexity of any object impedes global, integral and complete analysis. Object attributes that condition its study:

  • Any object is naturally dynamic and mutable.
  • The object may be real or ideal.
  • Some objects have delimitation problems.
  • A large part of the objects belong to, or occur in a phase of the time-space continuum, or rather flow along a section of that continuum.

Characters of Categories

  • Every category is a sectorial one.
  • Every category implies a specific level of analysis.
  • Categories are levels of analysis external to the object.
  • Categories are mutually excluding
  • Every category is highly generalizable.
  • Every category may admit, with reference to an object, variable levels of subdivision.
  • Agreement has not been reached regarding a limited collection of categories.

Conclusion and Reflection

At the end of the article the author proposes greater attention should be shown to this topic. I have to agree with that along with requesting that it be in simpler terms. After two readings my mind is still boggling with some of the terms and ideas. The references to the time-space continuum made me think of a play I know that involved paradoxes. I can only hope that I will understand this topic more after my class tomorrow night.

Wednesday, April 11, 2007

I Am A - L - I - V - E !

Yes I am still here.

I am extremely busy with the new position and the end of the semester!

Let's recap -- shall we?

I found out I got mono right before break and therefore break was not very much fun as I mostly slept and packed the things I wanted to bring back with me. It also snowed three times -- not so much fun. I flew back to school on St. Patty's Day and subsequently got stuck in the Chicago airport for 5 hours. I was not a happy camper as all I wanted to do was be in bed and once I got to my destination I still had an hour drive ahead. While I was in the airport I did however see a sleeping leprechaun -- very cool...very cool indeed! So I finally got home around 1am only to have to go back out and find the 24hr pharmacy to get cough syrup.

I learning something new every day at the new J O B and am slowly but surely learning my way around town -- soon I'll be able to get here, there and everywhere.

Last night I impressed some folks with my ability to quote Dr. Seuss it was a rant about Green Eggs and Ham. The things that are in my mind -- some day that will help get me a job -- right??

It was also told to me through several channels that I am not posting enough personal info...and keeping my loving family and friends informed of my goings on...I shall try my best..but you know a girl has to have some mystery right??

Hope everyone had a Happy Easter!!

TTFN~

LS 500 How a Search Engine Works

Liddy, E. (2001). How a Search Engine Works. Searcher 9(5):38-45.


A Search Engine is the more popular term for an Information Retrieval (IR) System. Whichever term you call the system it contains four different elements:

  • A Document Processor
  • A Query Processor
  • A Search and Matching Function
  • A Ranking Capability


Document Processor

Prepares, processes and inputs the documents, pages or sites that users are searching. Document processors perform some of the following steps:

  • Normalize the document stream to a predefined format
  • Break the document stream into retrievable units
  • Isolate and metatag subdocument pieces
  • Identify potential indexable elements in documents
  • Delete stop words
  • Stems terms
  • Extracts index entries
  • Computes weights
  • Creates and updates the main inverted file against which the search engine searches in order to match queries to documents


Query Processor

Query processing has seven possible steps:

  • Tokenize query terms
  • Recognize query terms vs. special operators
  • Delete stop words
  • Stem words
  • Create query representation
  • Expand query terms
  • Compute weights


Search and Matching Function

How systems carry out their search and matching functions change depending on which theoretical model of information retrieval underlies the system’s design philosophy. Searching the inverted file for documents meeting the query requirements, referred to simply as “matching”, is typically a standard binary search, no matter whether the search ends after the first two, five or all seven steps in the query process. Some search engines use algorithms for scoring not based on document content, but based on the relation among documents or past retrieval history of documents and pages. After the similarity is computed for each document in the subset of documents, the system presents an ordered list to the searcher. The sophistication of the ordering of the documents depends on the model the system uses as well as how advanced the document and query weighting mechanisms are. Some systems that are very sophisticated go the extra mile and let the user provide relevance feedback or modify their query based on the results they were given.


What Document Features Make a Good Match to a Query

Term Frequency

How frequently a term appears in a document is one of the most obvious ways to determine a document’s relevance to a query. However, several situations can undermine this premise. Many words have multiple meanings; such as “pool” or “fire.” Also in some domains certain words are so common and so frequent that their relevance declines sharply.


Location of Terms

Many search engines give preference to words found in the title or lead paragraph or in the metadata of a document. Terms that occur in the title of a document or page that match a query term are therefore frequently weighted more heavily than terms occurring in the body of the document. Also, query terms that occur in section headings or within the first paragraph of the document may be more likely to be relevant.


Link Analysis

Link analysis works like bibliographic citation practices. Link analysis is based on how well connected each page is as defined by Hubs and Authorities, where Hub documents link to large numbers of other pages (out-links) and Authority documents are those referred to by many other pages, or have a high number of “in-links.”


Popularity

Google and several other search engines use popularity to determine page relevance. Popularity uses data on the frequency that a page is chosen by users to predict the relevance of it.


Date of Publication

Some search engines assume that the newer the information is the more likely that it will be relevant to the user. These engines present the results beginning with the most current ones first followed by the older results.


Length

When there is a choice with two documents having the same query terms, the search engine chooses the document that has a higher occurrence of the term relative to the length of the document.


Proximity of Query Terms

When the terms occur near each other in a document it is more likely that the document is relevant to the query than if the terms occur at a greater distance.


Proper Nouns

These sometimes have a greater weight, since many searches are performed on people, places or things.


Summary and Reflection

Up till now search engine providers have primarily opted for less versus more complex processing of documents and queries. This then leaves the bulk of the work to be done by the searcher to pick their way through the results to find what they are seeking. Hopefully this status-quo will not continue and search engines will continue to enhance the quality of the processing.

I have to honestly say it never occurred to how or what exactly happens when I perform a search. It was interesting to learn exactly how complex the search process is and what all the different components are. Just today I saw an additional article (see below for link) from ZDnet.com that stated that Google is drawing 64% percent of the search queries for the month of March. Overall I found the article very enlightening and informative as to how the whole process works. I certainly won’t look at performing a search the same way again.


http://news.zdnet.com/2100-9595_22-6175248.html?part=rss&tag=feed&subj=zdnn

LS 500 Authority Challenges

Bennett, D.B. & Williams, P. (2006). Name Authority Challenges for Indexing and Abstracting Databases. Evidence Based Library and Information Practice, 1(1).

Introduction

Indexing and Abstracting (I&A) databases generally have not implemented name authority control as is used in many library catalogs. Most I&A databases burden the searcher with identifying and selecting name variations. The use of widely varied forms of authors’ names without reference or links to alternatives causes problems for the searchers. End results may be inaccurate or incomplete, resulting in a decrease in the scientific integrity of the research.

Individual library online catalogs have been applying authority control since the implementation of AACR2. Personal name authorities bring together works by an author, regardless of the variations in name as identified in the work itself.

One large challenge lies in managing author name changes. Few databases have chosen to link the variations or name changes to facilitate searching and retrieval of an author’s works. I&A databases may also move all of an author’s works from the former name to the current name, altering some records so then the author name no longer matches the name displayed on the original article.

Examples of Problems with Name Changes

Authors that publish works under two forms of their name and authors that have changed their names are both not easily found in databases and in most cases not all the relevant citations are found. If database citations do not contain the form of the name used on the article, citing errors most often will occur.

The Web of Science, the original citation tool, uses the author name exactly as it appears in the citing article. The policy of ISI is not to over-correct “variations” because it cannot check them all and refuses to second guess an author’s intentions.

When the searcher uses only the author name on an article but the I&A database has reformatted the author name and the user selects the name from the I&A database rather than the name on the article, some citations will not be retrieved.

Potential Solutions: Overview

Solutions to the problem of identifying and linking author name changes within I&A databases can take many approaches both in production and in the research modeling stage.

  • Authority Control through the use or linking of Name Authority files
  • Uses a file: MathSciNet or WilsonWeb
  • Proposed file: International Standard Authority Name/Data Number
  • Linking across files: HoPEC, ANAC Levy Project, LEAF

Name Disambiguation through automated methods

  • In Practice: Author-ity
  • Models in development by research teams, including use of social networks

Maintaining name authority files requires a high amount of labor but benefits the user with high recall and high precision results. Automated methods of name disambiguation require less manual labor but cannot compare to the level of high recall and high precision of well maintained authority files.

Potential Solutions: Authority File in the MathSciNet Database

The MathSciNet database creates and maintains a name authority file to control variations. Much of the identification process is automated; however around 20% of all the items require manual checking. MathSciNet’s solution is workable in small database communities, where it is possible for human indexers to check and correct all problem entries manually. It should be noted that this solution may not work for large databases, but it could prove very useful for databases covering a smaller range of information and topics.

Potential Solutions: More Examples Creating, Using, or Linking Authority Files

I&A Databases may follow Library of Congress (LC) practice but may get an added benefit in looking at the LC Name Authority File (LCNAF) to help with collocating the names in the author databases. I&A Databases would also benefit from the effort that goes into compiling the LCNAF. But the I&A make the mistake of changing the authors’ names rather than pointing or linking to the variations as given within the articles themselves.

Several projects are currently in the works to build on LCNAF and other authority files.

FRANAR – Functional Requirements and Numbering of Authority Records

“Is working to develop a conceptual model to assist in an assessment of the potential for international sharing and use of authority data both within the library sector and beyond.”

HoPEc System

Implements an author registration component that places the burden on the authors to create and maintain their own authority files if they wish for the papers to be clustered.

Librarians realized long ago that linking methods could be exchanged for authorized forms of names. In the automated environment a system does have to select a “correct” form as long as all of the variations link to each other.

LEAF Project – Linking and Exploring Authority Files

Links all authority records that pertain to the same person based on the automatic linking rules of the project and includes birth/death dates.

Potential Solutions: Alternative Approaches Using Name Disambiguation

Instead of using name authority files, researchers are aiming for an automated method of examining more than the author name to determine the likelihood that any two papers with similar author names have been written by the same person.

Authority name issues can be grouped into three categories: (1) multiple name variations that signify the same author, (2) similar or homonymic names that belong to more than one author and (3) linear changes when an author alters his/her name.

Disambiguation projects generally share similar attributes. All of them use metadata beyond the author name alone. Most have proven that adding more data elements to the models help to disambiguate names in a faster manner and with a higher rate of success than solely using single author names. Merging the techniques of adding data elements and relying on disciplines to maintain their own linked name files could garner great success for large, multidisciplinary databases such as I&A.

Conclusion

Alternative solutions must be implemented to assure access, retrieval and the proper crediting of authors’ works. Without control or linkage to name variations, searchers may retrieve incomplete or inaccurate results. To meet the access needs of the 21st Century both catalogs and I&A databases may need to implement options that present a high degree of probability that the items have been authored by the same individual rather than options that provide high precision with manual maintenance. Striving for name disambiguation rather than name authority control may be the best option for catalogs, I&A databases and digital library collections.

Developing automated methods can reduce the searchers burden of determining author name variations while ensuring that the author index entries match the names on the article and that the end user can successfully retrieve all of an author’s works from that database.

Reflection

Anything that furthers getting the correct packets of information to the user is something that we should be pursuing in library science. The average user does not know to look under the author name variations unless the search page tells them to do so and even then they may not read the instructions. I believe we need to focus on the quality of the results and ensure that people are finding what they are looking for and gaining good quality information. We must as a profession, do whatever is necessary to deliver the correct information in a quick and timely manner to those that are requesting it.

Saturday, March 31, 2007

LS 500 Three Decades Sine P & A

Knowlton, S.A. (2005). Three Decades Since Prejudices and Antipathies: A Study of Changes in the Library of Congress Subject Headings. Cataloging & Classification Quarterly 40(2):123-45.

In 1971 Sanford Berman wrote Prejudices and Antipathies: A Tract on the LC Subject Heads Concerning People (P & A) which listed numerous objectionable headings and proposed changes. The article compiles all of Berman’s suggestions and looks at the changes that have happened over the last thirty years and the biases that still remain.

The Problem of Biased Headings In LCSH

Since LCSH was first published it has come under microscopic review by librarians. Critics have examined the choice of terms, the syndetic structure and the inconsistency with which subject headings are formulated. Even with these objections the LCSH is the primary thesaurus for controlled vocabulary searching in libraries in the United States and around the world. With the increase use of LCSH and especially the world wide use Librarians continue to object about the bias in subject headings, especially those used to identify groups of people that perpetuate “the exclusionary cultural supremacy of the main-stream patriarchal, Euro-settler culture.” This means that a Subject Heading has a BIAS when it only uses language that shows a prejudice in favoring particular view points and against others.

The core of the bias problem is illustrated in the LCSH Operating Principles. David J. Haykin, chief of the Library of Congress stated, “The heading…should be that which the reader will seek in the catalog, if we know or can presume what the reader will look under.” This rule also ignores the notion of universal bibliographic control to which the LC also has a commitment to do. The article states the largest problem is the identity of the “average”reader: an American/Western European, Christian, White, Heterosexual and Male. LCSH with biases also makes materials harder to find for certain users, it stigmatizes certain groups of people with inaccurate and demeaning labels and creates the impression that certain points of view are normal while others are unusual. With the increased use of the LCSH into the four corners of the world, more and more librarians are objecting to the biases from as far away as Great Britain and Australia.

Sanford Berman’s Prejudices & Antipathies

The pioneer in calling attention to the biases has of course been Sanford Berman who wrote the paper that this article is examining. Berman’s goal was to, “question certain subject headings in LCSH and propose alterations, additions and deletions of headings in LCSH and propose alterations, additions and deletions of headings and cross references to more accurately reflect the language used in addressing these topics, to rectify errors of bias and to better guide librarians and readers to material of interest.” Berman’s paper was met with mixed reviews in the library press.

Changes to LCSH SINCE the Publication of P & A

Berman himself estimates that no more than half of his suggestions have been adopted.

Discussion

In reality P & A proved to be the cornerstone for changes in LCSH. “In the 225 headings that Berman suggested be changed 88 or 39% were changed almost exactly as he suggested and an additional 54 headings or 24% were changed in a way that partially reflects Berman’s suggestions. 80 items remain unchanged or 36% show patterns of thought that persist in the Library of Congress, one such example are the many subject headings that pertain to the Christian Religion remain unchanged.”

The article states that while the biases are a continuing source of concern they have been seriously addressed by the compilers of the LCSH. The main biases that still persist deal with unglossed religious headings that refer to Christian topics and terms relating to the United States history and geography, which would be confusing to users outside of the U.S.

Reflection

I am very glad to see that LCSH has taken the biases seriously and dealt with them accordingly since Berman wrote his paper. I think we need to be ever vigilant for the users of the future and make sure that things continue to change and that search terms are as inclusive as possible so that users world wide have an equal shot at finding the same information. Equal and easy access for all — isn’t that what we strive for as a profession? Making sure the information gets to those that need it most.

Friday, March 23, 2007

LS 500 Thesauri, Taxonomies & Ontologies Oh My!

Gilchrist, A. (2003). Thesauri, Taxonomies and Ontologies - An Etymological Note. Journal of Documentation 59:7-18.

This article attempts to clarify the differences and similarities between the three terms: Thesauri, Taxonomies and Ontologies as they are presently being used by Information Scientists, AI Practitioners, those working on the foundations of the Semantic Web as well as others.

The beginning of the article lists the definitions from the Oxford English Dictionary (OED):

Thesaurus

A "treasury" or "storehouse" of knowledge, as a dictionary, encyclopedia or the like.
A collection of concepts or words arranged according to sense; also a dictionary of synonyms and antonyms.

Taxonomy

Classification, esp. in relation to its general laws or principles; that department of science, or of a particular science or subject, which consists in or relates to classification; especially the systemic classification of living organisms.

Ontology

The science or study of being; that department of metaphysics which relates to the being or essence of things, or to being in the abstract.

Thesauri

The article mentions that the word thesaurus makes most lay people think of Roget's Thesaurus of English Words and Phrases (first published in 1852). I would be one of those people who thought of Roget; it also make me think of some kind of dinosaur that likes words, but that could just be my imagination taking over.

The next reference of the word comes from Wilkins' 1668 Essay Towards a Real Character and a Philosophical Language which included a decimal classification that ranged from God to "public relationships (civil, judiciary, naval, military, ecclesiastical)."

The third reference of the word thesaurus comes from a paper by Helen Brownson from the American National Science Foundation. Vickery quoted Brownson as saying "The application of a mechanized thesaurus based on networks of related meanings."

The article also points out some scholars are of the opinion that, "The thesaurus may become almost invisible to most users." The author suggests that the conventional thesaurus should be extended and elaborated to include: term definitions, notes on term usage and more explicitly defined relationships. One of the great benefits of these elaborations would allow the semantic network to be more easily manipulated by an interference engine, most likely an IF...Then operator.

Taxonomies

Inevitably individuals will introduce old words with new meanings into the conscious of the mainstream. This occurrence has renewed an interest in taxonomies; the triggers that generally cause this to happen are the following four things:

Information Overload - Conventional search engines are inadequate in dealing effectively with very large databases and users are in desperate need of search aids and filters.

Information Literacy - End users have severe problems in properly knowing how to search for information causing much time to be wasted and critical information to be missed.

Organizational Terminology - Published classifications and thesauri do not reflect the languages of particular organizations, in which most often 80% of the information is created internally.

"Destructuring" of Organizations - Mergers and acquisitions create cultural problems at the implementation stage. Similar issues have been encountered when extranets have been combined and when virtual communities are established.

Most frequently the word Taxonomy was being used with at least five separate meanings:

  1. Web Directories - on the Internet and more and more in Intranets
  2. Taxonomies to Support Automatic Indexing - commercial Web sites
  3. Taxonomies Created by Automatic Categorization - software packages capable of automatic analysis
  4. Front End Filters - a taxonomy created or imported and used in query formulation
  5. Corporate Taxonomies - A number of thesauri get merged into a "megathesaurus"

Ontologies

In Vickery's 1997 paper he quotes Gruber (a leader in the Ontology Field) as saying, "An ontology can be defined as a formal, explicit specification of a shared conceptualization."

WordNet and CYC are two of the oldest and most widely known ontologies. WordNet contains 100,000 word meanings grouped by five categories: nouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs and function words. Two areas where the use of ontologies is being touted prominently is in the area of Knowledge Management and in the idea of the Semantic Web.

The article mentions three kids of ontologies as being useful or organizational memory systems:

  • An Organizational Ontology - which describes the information meta-model
  • A Domain Ontology - which describes the content of the information source
  • An Enterprise Ontology - which is used for modeling business processes

Conclusion

The article quotes Wittgenstein as saying, "If you want to know the meaning of a word, you should look to see how it is used." Looking at the applications of thesauri, taxonomies and ontologies it is easy to see a progression of ideas that has resulted in some overlapping of detail. This progression has been driven mainly be three factors:

  1. The growing trend in organizations to collate external and internal information
  2. The vast quantities of information now available (Microsoft has 3 million documents on its Intranet)
  3. Available and Inexpensive Computing Power

The article states all three words (Thesauri, Taxonomies and Ontologies) all deal with natural language and notes that taxonomies use both classification and thesaurus techniques. In his final statement Gilchrist states it is very obvious that multidisciplinary teams will be needed if such dreams as the Semantic Web are to become a reality.

~ My Perspective ~

Well first and foremost I have to say that I understood the article much more after attending class. I don't think you should have to read the article two or three times to fully understand the concepts. At points I felt that the author was just blathering on to hear himself blather.

The one point that seems to come up time and time again is that users do not know how to search properly, get frustrated wasting time and miss the most valuable and useful information that they are searching for. My other main complaint with the article is that Mr. Gilchrist uses the term AI at least three times in the article. At no point does he clarify what it means or uses it in a context that I was able to gleam the meaning from. I am therefore left to assume (and I hate to assume) that it means Artificial Intelligence. What exactly that has to do with the three terms the article discusses I am not quite clear. At this point I'm quasi-clear on the three terms since class but I still don't like the article as a whole. I think it could have been done in a much clearer manner that the lay people category (which apparently I fit into from his Roget's Thesaurus comparison) could understand.

Wednesday, March 21, 2007

FRBR Blog

I made it onto the FRBR Blog!

Here's an email my professor sent:

Congrats, Kelly ... you make us proud!

http://www.frbr.org/2007/02/20/kelly-clinker

Dr. M

Friday, March 2, 2007

LS 500 Authority Control...

Gorman, M. (2003). Authority Control in the Context of Bibliographic Control in the Electronic Environment. Paper presented at the International Conference on Authority Control, Florence, Italy. February 10-12, 2003.

Michael Gorman begins the article by stating that bibliographic control is impossible without authority control. “Cataloging cannot exist with standardized access points and authority control is the mechanism by which we achieve the necessary degree of standardization.”

Gorman examines the fundamentals of cataloging and the three parts that make up a catalog record:

  1. Access Point
  2. Bibliographic Description
  3. Location or the Document Itself

Authority Records

Gorman then examines the five components of an authority record and even adds a sixth component that he feels it is lacking:

  1. To record the standardized form of each access point
  2. To ensure the gathering together of all records with the same access point
  3. To enable standardized catalogue records
  4. To document the decisions taken, and sources of, the access point
  5. To record all forms of the access point other than the one chosen as the normative form
  6. To record precedents and other uses of the standardized access point for the guidance of catalogers *This was Gorman’s addition*

From whence does the content of authority records come?

Gorman lists *some* of the sources that have to be taken into consideration when constructing a catalog record:

  • Existing national and local authority files
  • Applicable cataloging code, subject heading list, etc…
  • Document being cataloged
  • Reference sources

Metadata and authority control

Gorman discusses his dislike for OCLC’s Dublin Core at length and gives his definition of metadata, which is as follows:

Metadata – literally “data about data” which arose from the wishes of non-librarians to improve the retrievability of web pages and other internet documents. Metadata’s basic concept is the sufficient recall and precision in searching databases without the time consuming and expensive processes of standardized cataloging.

Authority control and the content of bibliographic records

Gorman states the Dublin Core cannot succeed in databases of any size as their random subject, name, title and series denotations are not held up to any kind of standardization or vocabulary control. Gorman states this will lead to *inchoate* results as the databases grow and that eventually the results will be no better than using a free text search on the internet.

*Inchoate* from www.Merriamwebster.com

:being only partly in existence or operation : incipient; especially : imperfectly formed or formulated : formless, incoherent inchoate suspicions that all is not well with the nation — J. M. Perry>

Precision and recall

Gorman explains all retrieval systems depend on two things – Precision and Recall. In the perfect system all records retrieved would relate 100% to the search terms and all relevant records would be retrieved 100%.

Solutions

Gorman proposes two options to fix the problems that currently exist and will only get worse as the information increases in the future.

One – Abandon the whole idea of metadata as something that will be useful to librarians and library patrons.

Or

Two – Invest metadata schemes with the attributes of traditional bibliographic records.

Gorman fires bullet after bullet as to what is wrong and what will happen if we don’t fix it:

  • The use of people without the skill and experience of catalogers to complete metadata templates will lead to incoherent, unusable databases.
  • REAL cataloging is inevitably time consuming and complicated.
  • The world of recorded knowledge and information is complicated and the number of complications tends to be indefinite.
  • It is impossible to conceive of a system that allows for consistent retrieval of relevant information while lacking any guidelines whatsoever.

Conclusion

In his conclusion Gorman holds nothing back and states that Authority Control and Cataloging are what enable the library to pursue its central missions of service and free and open access to all recorded knowledge and information. Gorman states, “We cannot have real library service without a bibliographic architecture and we cannot have that bibliographic architecture without authority control. It is as simple and as profound as that.”

Critical Reflection

I do believe with what Gorman states through out his article. I am a firm believer in the motto – “If you are going to do something, Do It Right.” As my grandfather would most likely say don’t do it half hearted (o.k. grandpa would have used more colorful language, but you get the gist).

The more that I learn about metadata the more I learn that it can be a fabulous thing if done properly. I also believe that I was using metadata or trying to create it before I knew what it was. In a former position I was in charge of the creation of a database. I found it very difficult to explain at least to some of my coworker’s satisfaction why it was so imperative that the data be entered so carefully. There was more than one that just wanted the information loaded willy~nilly so that the database would be up and running as soon as possible. This previous example was more than 10 years ago – ah the 90’s (cue your own flashback here).

Most recently I found a website that deals with the music tracks and metadata that they contain www.musicbrainz.org So it seems to me that metadata is here to stay, as Gorman said we may or may not choose to use it – so I guess part of the future is unwritten, only time will tell the true tale of whether metadata is to be or not to be.

LS 521 Journal Entry for 02/27/07

So Lucky is still in the news and the irony is that the more the book gets talked about the more it is going to sell and well isn't that exactly what every author wants -- For Their Book To Fly Off The Shelves!!

Apparently the Ladies of ABC's The View have taken notice and dared to say the naughty 'scrotum' word live on the air. However Barbara Walters did refer to the Newbery Award using the wrong name and also seemed to be confused regarding banning a book and challenging a book according to the reports I read.

I also read an account of a Librarian from New Mexico's account of when she read the book to some children and think it is worth noting. So here it is:

I read the opening 2 or 3 pages of Lucky to a third grade class this afternoon. I prefaced the reading by saying this was this year's Newbery award winner, and that it also was the subject of a front page article in the New York Times over the weekend because some people had objected to something in the first couple of pages. I told them I would read the beginning of the book to them, and for them to listen very carefully to see if they could figure out what was objected to. I did give them a little background on Lucky and AA, and Hard Pan so they'd have a little context.

I read from the beginning through the snakebite sentence, and although I shot a glance out over the room, no one giggled or reacted in any way. I read a a couple of paragraphs more, then asked if anyone had any idea yet. Like Monica's students, a couple of children suggested the
drinking and smoking as objectionable.

So, I told them that it was the part about the dog being bitten on the scrotum, which was a part of male mammal anatomy. They looked at me rather incredulously, like why would anyone object to that?

Then I read a bit more, and at the second mention of the incident, where it talks about the dog being bitten in a most sensitive place, some of them giggled.

I finished Sammy's story about Roy, and the kids didn't want to hear any more, even though I gave them a bit of a synopsis of the basic situation of the story. Actually, as I read about Sammy being dead drunk, I began to feel uncomfortable reading this to third-graders -- more
uncomfortable than reading the word "scrotum." I've been thinking all the rest of the afternoon about why this book is over the heads of third graders. Although I hesitate to generalize about
age groups (I had some excellent readers in this group, and some very sharp students), I think that developmentally the book is more suited to slightly older students -- 4th and maybe even better 5th or 6th graders. Part of it is the structure of the book -- the movement back and forth between Sammy's story and Lucky's listening, and her thoughts as she listens, which makes the story much more reflective than plot-driven. Awareness of the complexities of the adult world at the level presented here is, I think, beyond the developmental level of most third graders. Perhaps they are not yet able to move that far beyond themselves. I think interest in issues of the adult world increases as they become 4th and 5th and 6th graders. Indeed, Patron has said that she wrote the book for the 10-year-old inside of her.

Next step is to try this out on some older kids, or give it to their teachers to read.

The kids didn't even notice the naughty bits. When are adults going to learn that kids get their ideas from adults. Hopefully they get their morals and ideals from their parents as well. In my opinion there are a lot worse words out there that I have heard young kids use in normal conversation that I don't think I learned until I was high school. Gah! People are goofy sometimes especially the adults that are supposed to be in charge. Do we lose brain function as we get older or something? Thankfully as pop music has told us, "The Children are Our Future," I just hope we don't ruin it for them.

LS 521 Journal Entry for 02/20/07

There has been a great to-do over recent Newbery Winner Susan Patron's The Higher Power of Lucky because it uses the word scrotum. There I said it and see the world didn't implode.

For more information here is the wiki about the book.

What concerns me the most about all this hub-bub is not the fact that people are up in arms over the use of the word. But that LIBRARIANS are part of the people that speaking the loudest about boycotting, banning and or censoring this book from their libraries.

It is also interesting to note that the author Susan Patron herself is a librarian. What also concerns me is that those that have not even read the book speak out against it the loudest sometimes.

I am on a number of librarian listservs and this subject has been broached on all of them in some way, shape or form. It scares me a little that individuals that are this highly educated can be so narrow-minded in forming an opinion about a book before actually reading it. I am currently in the process of obtaining my graduate degree for Library Science -- is this what I will become? I certainly hope not.

Librarians are normally the ones fighting against censorship not the ones advocating for it.

For other examples in youth literature where the word scrotum has been used take a gander at this page.

For an Ohio Journalist's take on the whole issue here is an article from the Cleveland Plain Dealer.

Finally here is the author, Susan Patron's response to the whole controversy.